Political Pressure Has No Place in Scientific Authorship
A recent case involving the removal of a researcher's name from an academic paper has drawn attention. The Foundations of Physics journal recently agreed to an Idaho State University's request to remove the name of Emanuele Zappala, a professor of applied mathematics at the university, from the paper. The reason was not academic misconduct, but the fact that one of the co-authors was a tenured professor at Fudan University in China.
The incident is a consequence of U.S. restrictions on scientific collaboration with China. In a letter to the journal's editor, Martin Blair, Idaho State University's vice president for research and economic development, stated that the university does not allow its researchers to co-publish papers with collaborators from institutions on the U.S. Department of Defense's Section 1286 List.
The list identifies foreign institutions that the U.S. government considers to be engaged in "problematic activities." Most of them are based in China. In July, Fudan University and other Chinese entities were added to the list.
What is equally concerning is the role played by Idaho State University in this case. According to Carlo Rovelli, chief editor of the journal and founder of the quantum gravity group at France's Centre de Physique Théorique, the university forced Zappala into agreeing to the removal of his name.
On the other hand, while Section 1286 primarily restricts the use of Defense Department funding for research collaborations involving listed entities, Idaho State University extended the restrictions to all research co-publications involving its researchers and those institutions. Rovelli described the university's decision as "particularly absurd".
Interfering with academic authorship is a blatant violation of the scientific spirit. Academic papers are not only records of research findings but also part of the historical record of human scientific and technological progress. They embody researchers' intellectual contributions, dedication and hard work.
Having participated in the research and contributed to its findings, Zappala is entitled to authorship credit. Removing his name simply because he collaborated with a researcher affiliated with a Chinese institution amounts to an arbitrary alteration of the academic record and violates the fundamental principles of science.
As Rovelli put it, such an attitude is "contrary to the basic values of science."
Moreover, Zappala's experience sends a dangerous message to his colleagues and researchers across the U.S.: Academic contributions made in collaboration with Chinese scientists can be erased at will. This is likely to intensify the chilling effect on scientific research and undermine normal academic exchanges between China and the U.S. Some U.S. researchers may consequently begin or deepen their practice of "self-censorship," avoiding or scaling back collaborations with their Chinese counterparts.
For Idaho State University, forcing the removal of Zappala's name from the paper damages its own academic reputation and international standing. Extending restrictions to research collaborations with the listed Chinese institutions also risks undermining the university's research output and international cooperation.
In an interview with the media, Rovelli strongly criticized the university's actions, saying he had never encountered anything similar in "many decades of academic life." Zappala had previously co-authored seven papers and one preprint with his Fudan University collaborator. This stable, productive and ongoing research relationship has now been seriously disrupted.
It is important to recognize, however, that this does not represent the universal position of U.S. universities. The paper has two other American co-authors, but their universities did not take similar action. Idaho State University's decision reflects a broader problem: mounting pressure from the U.S. government on universities over research collaboration with China.
In August, the U.S. Department of Defense directed 30 universities to conduct comprehensive reviews of their collaborations with entities on the Section 1286 List, warning that failure to address identified concerns could jeopardize their eligibility for federal research funding.
On October 19, Emil Michael, the department's under secretary for research and engineering, reiterated the funding threat in a news release, warning that institutions failing to meet "research security standards" would not receive taxpayer funding.
International collaboration is an indispensable driver of scientific progress, and academic authorship should never be subject to political interference. The U.S. government should not extend geopolitical divisions into the academic sphere.
American universities, meanwhile, should foster an open and supportive environment for research collaboration and serve as guardians of scientific principles and academic freedom, rather than becoming accomplices and instruments in undermining international scientific cooperation.